I've had two pair of these thinking the first time the sole separated was just a fluke but when the same thing happened to the second pair I changed brands.

I usually like Johnston & Murphy shoes but I am not a fan of this one. I have had them for 4 months and they are falling apart. The leather is peeling off of the shoe and now they look tacky. I will not buy this kind again.

I don't usually write reviews, but these shoes are the most comfortable dress shoes I've ever put on. All of the J&M shoes with the sheepskin lining are ridiculously comfortable. Like wearing slippers lined with pillows. I bought a pair of similar J&M casual brown shoes with the sheepskin lining the same day I bought these. So long Cole Haan, Kenneth Cole, and Clarks.

The leather looks like cheap plastic, dull and spongy. The lines of the styling on the shoes are broad and puffy, not sharp and classy, giving the styling the look of orthopedic shoes. It's too bad because they are very comfortable. J&M must do better.

I am not a runner, but I do walk every day a minimum of 4 miles. I am also a big guy (6ft, 235lbs) and my first priority in a shoe is great cushioning. So far, my brands of choice were Brooks, New Balance and Salomon. In total, I own about 20 pairs of sneakers. When I heard of Hoka One One, I researched the brand as max as I could and was impressed by the positive comments and decided to purchase these shoes. Let me tell you: I am absolutely stunned at how good this shoes are. I thought the max comfort I could ever find was something like a Brooks Trance 11. Well, this Hoka One One just blows the Trance 11, and every other shoes I own, out of the water, no contest! Most comfortable pair of shoes I have ever owned. Sure they're expensive, but what you get is just an amazing shoe.

After a knee injury during a half marathon, I switched shoes and trained for and ran a full marathon in these shoes. I absolutely love the support and energy return that these shoes provide. I am a recovering minimalist runner, and I have never felt so light on my feet than I have in these shoes. You would never believe it by looking at them. The toe box is huge, and my feet are very happy with the room they have in these shoes. I am 5'8" 135 lb female, and I average about 25-35 miles per week running. I have multiple foot and joint issues, including ITBS in my knee and hallus rigidus in my foot. These are both pre-arthritic conditions that flare up on occasion and hurt when I run, but in these shoes the pain is virtually 100% gone. These are also my go-to shoe for long distance walking and lots of time spent on my feet, such as all day at Walt Disney World. No foot pain whatsoever. By far the best shoes I have ever purchased. I just wish they weren't so funny looking :).

I have plantar fasciitis and have found Hoka One to be wonderfully helpful. Two other people in my family have now bought the shoes with favorable results. I would like to purchase other colors but the sizes are always sold out.

These shoes are unbelievably expensive, but so worth the money. I will definitely order another pair of these in the future. I have plantar fasciitis and arthritis in my joint in my big toe. I have tried a lot (I mean a lot) of other brands and have never found anything that compares to the comfort these shoes provide me for my P.F. I am so glad I spent the money for these shoes. I wear them all day long and have very little to no pain in my feet. I wear a 10.5 and ordered a 10.5. They are true to size, very roomy in the toebox and I like the bungee lace system. Makes it easy to tighten or loosen the shoe if I need. Also easy slip on/off. I also overpronate and require a stability shoe. I was afraid these shoes would be too bouncy, but I have not had any problems whatsoever. I used to run a lot, but since my P.F. I haven't been able to run for many years. Walking alone has been difficult over the years. I wasn't able to walk for more than 15 without having to sit down because of the pain in my feet. I am happy to say this is no longer true while I am wearing these shoes. I can walk longer and faster with these shoes on which is more than I have been able to do in a very long time. I am so happy I spent the money for these shoes. They are well worth the money for me. I recommend these shoes to everyone and I hope you enjoy them as much as I am.

I normally wear 10 2E running shoes in just about any brand. I was concerned that the size 10 Hokas would not be wide enough. They are fine. I am a supinator, so I have worn down the outside edge of the heel after less than 75 miles. I think the bottom material should stand up a little better than that, personally. Other than the aggressive wear, I am absolutely pleased with the Hoka Stinson EVOs. They immediately enabled me to increase distance. I have knee issues and the Hokas mitigate that very well.