Continue playing Product Showdown

Product Showdown

aka Shoe-Jitsu, Shoe-mo Wrestling, Shoe Duel, and a number of other witty names we couldn't decide on.

UGG Smithfield

Battle Stats

  • Total Wins: 8
  • Total Losses: 11
  • Wins vs. Competitor: 1
  • Sales Rank: #20048
  • Video Description View the Video Description for this product! (Please note that the color shown in the video may no longer be available.)
  • Fashionable indoors and functional outdoors, the Smithfield is perfection in a tall boot.
  • Rich waterproof leather and suede uppers with a knit wool cuff.
  • Decorative cross lacing detail with metal hardware down the back.
  • Full length inside side zipper for easy on/off.
  • Lined in genuine sheepskin for the ultimate in cozy comfort.
  • Comes with interchangeable leather and sheepskin insoles for customized comfort.
  • Rugged rubber outsole is water resistant and shock absorbing.
  • Care and Cleaning Instructions
  • UGG® Women's Size Chart
  • Heel Height: 1 in
  • Shaft: 14 12 in
  • Circumference: 16 12 in
  • Weight: 1 lb 8 oz
  • Product measurements were taken using size 7. Please note that measurements may vary by size.

Average Customer Ratings (based on 41 reviews)

Overall: (4 Stars) Comfort: (4 Stars) Style: (4 Stars)

Posted: 2009-10-30 16:29:23
Reviewer: Anonymous from nyc
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (4 Stars)
I needed a quality weatherproof boot for daily city commute and an occasional ski trip. The Classic Ugg(lie)s, no thanks. Same goes for knee high galoshes (yuck). But this shearling-lined, waterproof, leather boot, with a laced up back is this season's winner for me. -1 star for square toe, but I am willing to compromise that much to keep my feet comfy and toasty until the spring. True to size (8.5), but snug width on my wide foot. I have a 15.5" calf and it's snug around there, too (able to tuck in pencil jeans). Removable shearling insole, nice. Thanks Zappos!
Posted: 2009-11-01 23:17:23
Reviewer: Debi M from New York
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
I have always loved the Ugg brand. Have been very unfortunate in that I can rarely wear them due to having flat feet. I got these boots & they are the most comfortable, classy & warm boots ever. They fit more like the Frye styled boots, but much lighter in weight. They look sexy with skirts & outrageous with jeans. I can easily tuck my skinny jeans in them & I have a wider calf. I adore them so I may have to go back for the other color (I have them in black)! Order true to your size & if you need to, can go up 1/2 size & be fine.
Posted: 2009-11-02 21:18:25
Reviewer: Judi D from S.Calif
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
I purchased these boots for an upcoming trip to New York and Spain. Since it rained here a few weeks ago, I decided to give them a test. I wore then for the first time all day in and out of the rain. Very comfortable, size was perfect, looks with skirt or pants is great. I recommend these boots highly.
Posted: 2009-11-05 07:42:16
Reviewer: Dena J from Cedar Rapids
Overall: (4 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (4 Stars)
Such a gorgeous boot! I somehow missed the phrase 'Decorative' in the description above and I thought that the laces were functional. So not the case, and alas the lovely boot would not accommodate my 17 inch calves. However the boot is well worth the price. There is a beautiful subtle crosshatched design on the suede portion of the boot, sort of a cross between a plaid & a stripe. I cried when I discovered that they would not work. If at 2nd you don't succeed try, try again!
Posted: 2009-11-07 16:46:21
Reviewer: Marcia from fort worth texas
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Just not fitting right. Saw these boots in the Ugg ad and thought they looked great. Really disappointing that the laces do not work. I also tried two different sizes to accommodate my wider calf. Tried 7.5 and 8, and I am regularly a 7. Neither size worked well. The foot part was roomy enough but the upper part of calf was too tight. The 8 was even tighter on one leg than the 7.5. Also, zipper didn't work well on the 7.5. One last thing, these boots are not slimming in the least. Had my sister try them on and even with her skinny legs, it made her look hefty in the calves. So, I am returning them. Still looking for something.
Posted: 2009-11-09 16:15:48
Reviewer: Pam D from Mt. Shasta California
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (3 Stars)
These boots are awesome. I can't wait until it snows here. I love everything about them except for the square toe. But I will deal with that. They fit great, feel great, and except for that toe, they look great. I would get these again.
Posted: 2009-11-24 02:51:08
Reviewer: Anonymous from Northern New York state
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
I am very pleased with my Ugg Smithfields. My feet are on the wide-ish side, and these are quite comfortable. I normally wear an 8.5, and the size 9 boots are a perfect fit. I put both the regular and the sheepskin insoles inside, for maximum padding and softness. I always wear them barefoot, and they are very comfortable. It is great to have a pair of Uggs that are not suede on the bottom; I'll be able to get these wet and not worry so much about ruining them. The styling on the back of these boots is particularly cute. The lacing is a very cool touch, and I've gotten many compliments.
Posted: 2009-11-27 13:24:15
Reviewer: Cheryl B from Chicago, IL
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (4 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
I have been eyeing these for a few months now, and after hearing a New Yorker Podcast about how great Zappos is, I finally bought these. First, I in general despise the classic Ugg as a winter boot; Uggs are made for the beach after surfing, not the snow (and not for mini skirts. please). These, however, are made for real weather. Waterproof, well insulated (it comes with two insoles, one padded, one sheepskin, for different degrees of warmth), and a great rubber sole. In terms of style, the contrast between leather and suede was much more attractive than it looks online, and I love the wool collar; it adds a level of texture and luxe to the somewhat rugged boot. The decorative lacing on the back (it doesn't function) is the perfect touch. I have narrow calves (about 14"), and with jeans and smart wool socks, these boots fit perfectly. If you calves are more than 15", I'd be careful. The specs say the circumference is 16.5", but when you take into account the sheepskin, you lose a lot of room. The shoes are also on the narrow side. Unlike another reviewer, I completely disagree that these run big. I listened and got a half size larger than normal, and they were way too big. A 7 1/2 left almost an inch of space in the toe. If anything, I think these run quite large; don't forget that sheepskin should be rather tight because as it becomes matted, she shoe feels larger. Ugg stores stress this fact. This is the best not-ugly but functional winter boot I have yet to find.
Posted: 2009-11-30 07:23:52
Reviewer: Anonymous from Kansas
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
These boots really are warm, waterproof, and comfortable. The first time I wore them, I walked over a mile through slush and puddles during a very wet snowfall in downtown Denver and my feet did not get wet or cold. The price is worth it.
Posted: 2009-12-01 18:24:14
Reviewer: Michelle from Syracuse, NY
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
I just wanted to give my input on these shoes. I so wanted these boots and had been eying them for months. However, I know that boots can run different then most shoes and wanted to actually try on before I purchased. I was able to do this and agree with some of the other reviewers. I have a small foot size 6 but a wider calf (only about 15 inches) and was not able to zip this boot up all the way unless I went up in size to a 7.5. I do have other UGG products and love them and if at first you don't achieve your shoe purchasing goal, try try again. So I am still on the look out for fun brown boots. love Zappos though and never have any issues with returning if necessary.

Trotters Ash

Battle Stats

  • Total Wins: 90
  • Total Losses: 124
  • Wins vs. Competitor: 0
  • Sales Rank: #4523
  • Video Description View the Video Description for this product! (Please note that the color shown in the video may no longer be available.)
  • Slip into casual comfort with the Ash slip-on from Trotters®.
  • Genuine nappa glove leather or micro stretch uppers.
  • Smooth lining prevents painful rubbing during wear.
  • Padded footbed provides superior shock absorption.
  • Flexible TPR composite outsole for easy walking.
  • Heel Height: 1 12 in
  • Product measurements were taken using size 10. Please note that measurements may vary by size.

Average Customer Ratings (based on 273 reviews)

Overall: (4 Stars) Comfort: (4 Stars) Style: (4 Stars)

Posted: 2002-11-12 07:10:33
Reviewer: Anonymous from Oklahoma City, OK
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Great looking and comfortable This shoe gets 5 stars as far as I'm concerned. It's stylish and comfortable. I've received compliments each time I wore them.
Posted: 2002-11-20 09:32:11
Reviewer: Anonymous from Pennsylvania
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
The best shoes I ever bought! I was amazed at how comfortable and nice looking these shoes are. They are true to fit and feel more comfortable than bedroom slippers. I have very wide feet and problems with fallen arches at both the sides and balls of my feet as well as inflammation in the tendons of my feet, so I'm just miserable if my shoes are not comfortable, which is usually the case. These shoes are the exception and I'll be ordering another pair in a different color.
Posted: 2002-12-31 09:08:53
Reviewer: Lauren from Florida
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
These are just about the most comfortable shoes I've ever owned. I'm on my feet a lot and the discomfort I used to have with shoes I wore before just isn't a problem with these. I've bought several pairs and it's been a Godsend.
Posted: 2003-01-09 21:58:02
Reviewer: Anonymous from Los Angeles, California
Overall: (3 Stars) Comfort: (1 Stars) Style: (4 Stars)
Absolutely beautiful dressy shoes, but if you have a very wide foot you will not be able to wear these. I wear a size 8ww and have a wide boxy foot with high arches, I was not even able to get my foot all the way in these shoes-- first time I've ever experienced this with any shoe marked 8ww. So I'd say these shoes are better for people with narrow feet.
Posted: 2003-02-05 12:15:55
Reviewer: Faye from Mass
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
The best shoes I have ever had. Very glad I bought them.
Posted: 2003-02-15 12:41:38
Reviewer: Sue from Detroit, Michigan
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
I absolutely love this shoe. After I received the black, I immediately ordered the blue. They are wonderfully comfortable, true to size, and stylish. I would not recommond for people with wide feet. These are very stylish without being too trendy. They are very polished and professional looking for 'business casual' wear at the office. I absolutely love them.
Posted: 2003-02-22 14:48:39
Reviewer: T.jenkins from New Jersey
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
The only shoe in years that truly fit my wide feet! I own two pairs of the Trotter Ash (fudge and navy). I wear a 9ww and usually buy a 10w in other brands because ww are too difficult to find in a fashionable style. So basically, my shoes are too big. But since I have brought the Trotters Ash, I can't image wearing anything other than Trotters. These shoes really wear wonderfully on my feet. I know this sounds like a commerical, but I truly mean it. My husband wants me to buy several to have forever, so that I'll never be without my Trotters. He can't believe I finally found a shoe that fits my feet. We are both elated. So please make them in more colors (olive, tan, grey,). Thank you, T.Jenkins
Posted: 2003-02-27 07:44:22
Reviewer: Anonymous from Arkansas
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
A Great pair of shoes. I love these shoes! They look great with everything and they fit well. I ordered a pair...and now I want them in every color.
Posted: 2003-05-07 09:10:12
Reviewer: Barb from Maryland, USA
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Great shoes! Just what I need and want. The fit is true to size and comfortable. Fast shipping too!
Posted: 2003-06-20 20:19:08
Reviewer: Jennifer from San Francisco, California
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
WOW! These are the most comfortable shoes I have ever owned. After wearing them, I ordered a pair in every color!

Battle History

Previous Month June 2012
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30