Close but not quite - I've been looking for a long time for some flat boots that will fit my problem feet (hammertoes, very high insteps/arches, narrow heels, orthotics). These boots were close, but not quite right for me! They are very wide in the toes which is great for anyone who needs a little extra room in the toes. The insole is very thick and removable, so these boots can accommodate orthotics; however, once you remove the insole the remaining sole is very thin, flat, and flexible (no support at all). The insoles do have some arch support, though no arch support actually touches my arch so I can't really comment on how good it is! The boots also rub the back of my heel, but I'm not sure if that would improve after wearing them a while. Ultimately I am returning these boots because they just don't have enough depth through the front of my instep with the included insole, but don't fit quite right with my orthotics either. But they are still worth a try if you're looking for a flat boot with a wider toe box or a removable insole! These boots are not very flattering, though I think they look slightly better than Uggs and similar styles due to the more rounded shape in the toe and sole. But I didn't really expect a flat winter boot to look that great!

These boots are adorable and fairly comfortable. The tie string is going to take awhile to soften up, but everything else is super cute! I highly recommend you order a half size larger than you normally do for other brands of shoes. I am a true 9 and I ordered a 9.5 and they fit perfectly.

You'll like them.... Very attractive, comfortable, true to size, great quality at a great price.

A Classic, Gentleman's Shoe - A beautifully designed, well constructed shoe. It is comfortable out of the box and I have tiny, narrow feet- these shoes fit me perfectly. A high priced shoe designer currently has an almost identical shoe available for 3x the price. No complaints here!

Shoe felt true to size and true to width across the ball of the foot. However, for a "B" width, the heel is somewhat loose. Would have expected a more "snug" fit in the heel. Have not worn the shoe outside.

Very classy shoe. Virtually no break-in period...felt very good on first wearing and just got even more comfortable after a few days. The width may be slightly wider that marked, but for me that is a good thing. Highly recommend these shoes. This is my second pair of Florsheim's...the first pair lasted many years.

Florsheim edgar review - Heel of the left shoe... a little tight. But after a couple of days of wear. It fit comfortably. It seems like a good shoe, however, it is too new for me to tell how it will wear over time. Generally, I buy florsheim and I am usually happy with their products.