Continue playing Product Showdown

Product Showdown

aka Shoe-Jitsu, Shoe-mo Wrestling, Shoe Duel, and a number of other witty names we couldn't decide on.

Stila Smudge Pot

Battle Stats

  • Total Wins: 206
  • Total Losses: 177
  • Wins vs. Competitor: 1
  • Sales Rank: #21817
  • Video Description View the Video Description for this product! (Please note that the color shown in the video may no longer be available.)
  • The unique gel eyeliner and shadow in one is an innovative alternative to traditional powder and liquid formulas.
  • Has an inky intensity, perfect for achieving sultry smoky eye or cat eye looks.
  • Apply with a liner brush for razor-sharp precision, or smudge for a more smoldering effect.
  • Remember to always close the airtight lid to keep the gel soft and pliable.
  • Listed ingredients:
    isododecane, polyethylene, cyclopentasiloxane, trimethylsiloxysilicate, disteardimonium hectorite, lecithin, phenyl trimethicone, hydrogenated polyisobutene, propylene carbonate, barium sulfate, phenoxyethanol, [+/- mica, titanium dioxide (ci 77891), iron oxides (ci 77491, ci 77492, ci 77499), bismuth oxychloride (ci 77163), carmine (ci 75470), chromium hydroxide green (ci 77289), chromium oxide greens (ci 77288), ferric ferrocyanide (ci 77510), manganese violet (ci 77742), ultramarines (ci 77007)] <iln29130>
  • 0.14 oz

Average Customer Ratings (based on 14 reviews)

Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)

Posted: 2009-05-18 13:40:03
Reviewer: Diane R from Knoxville, TN
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Awesome - I just tried this for the first time and am impressed! It lasts and does not smudge.
Posted: 2009-08-31 07:49:18
Reviewer: Heidi M from NJ
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Excellent, excellent, excellent customer service. The representative was very accommodating and professional. Couldn't ask for any better service. Super fast Delivery! Will definitely do more business here and recommend this site to my family and friends. I must also state that the product I purchased, Stila Gel Smudge Pot Eyeliner, was fresh stock unlike the previous one I purchased from a retail store.
Posted: 2009-10-20 07:34:52
Reviewer: PseudoBritChick from Raleigh North Carolina
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
I have the smudge pot in three colors and I completely love this product! I never thought I\'d like a gel formula shadow/liner but this stuff doesn\'t move until you take it off...and that\'s key for me.
Posted: 2010-01-26 14:38:35
Reviewer: Debbie from Grays Harbor
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Love this product. Wish I would have found this years ago. Goes on nicely and wears all day.
Posted: 2010-03-06 16:14:13
Reviewer: Kathleen Z from McDonough, GA
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
I have to be honest, Stila’s Smudge Pot eyeshadow, Jade, is the nicest product I have ever applied to my eye lids. I’ve used many other brands, but none of them can compare to Smudge Pot. I was drawn to Jade because I have green eyes and this color really complements them. This product is not messy and goes on very smooth, you can make a perfect line or do the whole lid and more with ease. This product makes you feel like an artist. I even called my daughters in California, to share with them what a great product I purchased from Zappos
Posted: 2010-07-09 06:05:10
Reviewer: Anonymous from Midland, Texas
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Wow I have tried many different eyeliners and this one really works. It lasts all day until I take it off. Love it!
Posted: 2010-10-05 08:34:47
Reviewer: Anonymous from Redmond, WA
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
I\'ve been looking for a long time for an eyeliner that doesn\'t smudge off half way through the morning. This even stays on after long sweaty workouts, and washes off when I want it to!
Posted: 2011-04-07 12:38:42
Reviewer: Glori B from Golden Valley, AZ
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
I love Stilla! This Kitten is a real favorite of mine. I was skeptical that creamy eye shadow would crease, but this absolutely does not crease! And I also use it under my Bare Minerals eye shadows, and it works like a primer. Another way I use it, is to put a dab on the top of my cheekbones. It really brings out the blush and makes your cheeks high and radiant. There are so many uses for this product. I am planning on getting more colors and using them as eye liners, as well. Also, I use this product to put on my lips, and then add darker color gloss. The Smudge Pot keeps my lipstick/gloss in place much longer. Great product, several uses, making this an excellent buy for your money!
Posted: 2011-05-04 19:53:23
Reviewer: Wendy S
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
I have been on a mission to find an eyeliner that didn't smear down my face by mid-morning. I even quit wearing eyeliner altogether because I was getting so frustrated. Then I found smudge pot. After reading the reviews, I knew I had to try it. And yes, it is wonderful. I am wearing eyeliner again. And it is on my eyes, not down my face. Thanks again Zappos!
Posted: 2011-05-26 04:37:30
Reviewer: Anonymous from Hudson, NY
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
These smudge pots are brilliant! First bought the kitten -- great if you're in a hurry and just take your finger and smudge the light color all over your eyelid, add a bit of liner and run out the door. Then I bought the green and brown. Very useful; I especially like the green -- I use a thin brush (sold here) for a liner. These are reasonably priced I think and they're lots of fun to play with.

Josef Seibel Frita

Battle Stats

  • Total Wins: 29
  • Total Losses: 26
  • Wins vs. Competitor: 0
  • Sales Rank: #22902
  • Video Description View the Video Description for this product! (Please note that the color shown in the video may no longer be available.)
  • Please click here for the Josef Seibel footwear size guide.
  • Life is like a rolling tide. Make sure you don't get lost at sea and slip into the fisherman-inspired Frita sandal from Josef Seibel®.
  • Rich leather upper with side buckle closure to give you a custom fit.
  • Breathable leather lining wicks away moisture for a happy and dry foot.
  • Fully-padded leather insole provides cushioning and comfort all-day long.
  • Flexible synthetic outsole adsorbs shock while maintaining amazing grip.
  • Weight: 12 oz
  • Product measurements were taken using size 37 (US Women's 6-6.5). Please note that measurements may vary by size.

Average Customer Ratings (based on 31 reviews)

Overall: (4 Stars) Comfort: (4 Stars) Style: (4 Stars)

Posted: 2010-02-02 08:34:02
Reviewer: Anonymous from Texas
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
This shoe is an update on the Josef Seibel fisherman sandal of past. It is supportive, comfortable, has a great strong sole, is easy to slip on/off and generally is a great shoe. It runs true to size (the old style ran short) and should be great for Texas or just anywhere! The arch support is there, and just right so you feel protected when walking thither and yon. It is cute enough to wear with almost anything (except a fancy dress)...
Posted: 2010-02-02 13:09:37
Reviewer: Anonymous from Florida
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (4 Stars)
Wonderful, comfortable shoe. Don't want to take them off ! I am on my feet all day with my job and these are perfect. Very happy. Good arch support.
Posted: 2010-02-23 00:55:04
Reviewer: Anonymous
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Great shoes. they were comfortable and I wore them to work, standing for 8 hours the first day. They are wider than others Josef Seibel's I have bought in the past and I was able to wear a 38 when I usually wear a 39.
Posted: 2010-03-04 09:11:37
Reviewer: Suzie from Texas
Overall: (3 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (3 Stars)
I am so torn between keeping this sandal and returning it! Fits like a dream and extremely comfortable sole for walking. However... the toe box is so wide that it gives the end of my foot the platypus effect! I feel like I am wearing flippers. Needless to say that doesn’t make your legs look too attractive either. I am tempted to keep them as a comfortable travel sandal, however, I am afraid that I will end up not wearing them because they are just not pretty on the foot. They are a heavy sandal - probably because of the good sturdy walking sole. If they were less expensive, I would probably keep them.
Posted: 2010-05-25 05:53:49
Reviewer: Anonymous from Highland, Indiana
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (2 Stars)
You can't beat Josef Seibel for quality; however, the "European" styling of their shoes does take some getting used to in my opinion. These shoes are very well-made, comfortable [no breaking in period for me] and get the job done when I need to slip something on to run errands. However, I personally do not think they look good on my feet. If you're a "mom" jeans or "mom" shorts type of lady, these might work well for you [too]. Bottom line: great quality, comfort, however not the most attractive shoe.
Posted: 2010-05-25 18:22:13
Reviewer: Anonymous from Indianapolis IN
Overall: (4 Stars) Comfort: (4 Stars) Style: (4 Stars)
I love the shoes, they're a little tight through the ball of the foot, but otherwise I love them. I wore them on vacation and after they stretched, it was like walking barefooted in them.
Posted: 2010-07-08 08:19:39
Reviewer: Anonymous from Central Oregon
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
These are beautifully well made shoes of top quality leather as one would expect of Josef Seibel. I used the word "shoes" and not "sandals" purposefully as given the wonderful tight weave of the fisherman styled front. They really are enough shoe that you can get away with trouser socks under them with slacks and have them look good. Not to mention the benefit of a sandal with a removable insole for folks who might use orthotics. Great option! That said, I really was torn about keeping these, but decided they were not enough "sandal" and too much"shoe" for what I needed right now. However, very comfy, although less comfy barefoot for me than with trouser socks and I tried them on both ways. I wear a 40 (9.0) in Seibel shoes and in this style the left foot was just big enough that it slid around without a sock on. I ordered another Seibel shoe (size 40) in this same Zappos order (Lindsay 2) and it fits like a glove on both feet. And closing on fit, I chuckled at the comments of another Zappos customer who described these shoes are giving a platypus effect to her feet. That's because I always say I have platypus toes...that is my toes are almost exactly square across the top! So a shoe with a wider toe box but a nice medium fit elsewhere with good heel grip are essential for me. And these fit that bill for sure. Including the adjustable mary jane strap across the top. I thought they looked darned attractive on, just more "shoe" than I wanted. But for comfort and design I'd recommend them to others looking for a dressier casual sandal for travel or office wear.
Posted: 2010-07-26 19:07:42
Reviewer: Anonymous from portland oregon
Overall: (4 Stars) Comfort: (4 Stars) Style: (4 Stars)
Comfortable - as is almost always the case with JSeibel. \r\n\r\nStyle not quite as polished. Good as casual summer shoe though.
Posted: 2010-08-15 12:12:10
Reviewer: Anonymous from Columbus, OH
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
It\'s hard to find a comfortable, attractive summer shoe that\'s not open toe. These are great with jeans, shorts and casual pants and very comfortable.
Posted: 2010-10-03 20:41:38
Reviewer: Alice A from San Francisco
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
These shoes are the best that I have had in a long time! They are well constructed, the leather is so very soft, and the sole is very sturdy. There was no break-in period; from day one, these shoes continue to be fantastic. I teach PreK, so that means that I am on my feet all day - nothing has been rubbing, squishing, or in anyway bothering my feet in these shoes. I think that they are also very cute, and therefore, I even ordered a pair in black, in addition to the brown. I highly recommend these shoes and Zappos is the best. Your service is terrific!

Battle History

Previous Month June 2012
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30