Cute but not as stated - Very stylish, nice suede and looks good. Definitely not a 16" width in calf. I also ordered the Wide in foot, they felt very narrow and tight.

Cute, but fall easily - This boot is so, so cute...but unfortunately, even just after wearing them around the house for 10 minutes, they started to fall down...slouching uncomfortably. The lack of zipper is the culprit, I believe. They fit well with jeans (and I have a wide calf), but not without. I was afraid they would stretch out even more. Still hunting for the perfect brown boot!

2tight4- Shoes looks really nice and stylish, even on my big size 11 feet, but the square front is just too tight, same goes for the middle piece. It just cuts into the flat area on your middle foot.

High arches? At this price, you must at least try these - I own these in red and just ordered them in black and camel. Here's the thing: they have amazing arch support. I'm not just talking cushiony padding, which they also have, but I mean real support. I'm constantly on the lookout for shoes I can walk in, because I walk a LOT and my arches are high. The Dansko clog line works well, but sometimes you want something a little neater looking. I also have a quite high instep and though the instep on these isn't baggy and I think I did have to break them in a bit - it's fine now. And the strap just fits on me, no gapping of velcro though I think there might have been when I first got them. I also have a widish foot and these feel fine and look trim. Bottom line is, if you need support and you like how these look, give them a try especially at this price. and esPECIALLY at zappos, with their great attitude and free return shipping! I usually wear a 9.5 or sometimes a 9 and I wear a 40 in these. I actually think that's pretty true to size - in Danskos, I have to wear a 41 (except the dansko sport clogs which are longer, I wear a 40). I wear a 40 in Birkenstock Arizona and 41 in Birkenstock Annapolis. I mention so you can make the best size choice :)