Looks much better in picture than when you wear it. Pro: soft, good-quality leather with warm inner lining. Cons: bad fit -- calf too big, too slouchy. Stitching and glue details are messy. I had originally wanted equestrian style boots that look pretty much exactly like this. I was really excited, but when I actually tried them on, they made my calves gain 5 pounds each. Not a fitting boot, too loose around the calf and ankles. Also looks really weird when you fold up the flaps to go over your knee. Overall too slouchy and loose. Most disappointing thing was probably that I can still see visible remnants of glue and poor stitching on the elastic/heel areas.

Perfect in all areas - I had been looking for a pair of these boots for a while, and as soon as I saw them here at Zappos, I ordered them. Free shipping, can't go wrong with that. When they came I was shocked. First of all that they came so quickly, so I'm pleased, and the boots fit so perfectly. I'm 5ft. 9'', and they go right by my knees. Good quality. For anyone who likes these, don't give it a second thought, order them, it’s worth it.

I just ordered these in grey, and the service at Zappos is unreal. Ordered these on Friday, and received them on Monday. These boots are a little disappointing, they look cheap. I have large athletic calves (16.5 inches), so I was able to pull them up. They just didn't look good on me, so I'm sending them back.

Great comfortable boot - I love these boots. I have "athletic" calves so it is difficult to find tall boots that I can wear. I purchased the grey leather. Although the leather quality is not the best (but what can you expect for the price of these boots), they look very stylish and I have received numerous compliments. In addition they are very comfortable, a requirement since I walk to almost everything. Zappos service is the best. They are always quick and easy to deal with.

Too slouchy, no cushion in the footbed. I like these boots with skinny jeans but they don't stay over the knee for any length of time, especially when worn with bare legs. I am considering taking them to a repair shop to get the calves narrowed in the hopes that will help. The overall fit is fine, but the lack of cushion in the footbed causes a problem for me.

I have been a loyal And1 customer for many, many years, and this shoe ranks up there with the best of them. The shoe has great heel cushoning, a responsive toebox, and a strap that locks you in and gives a good fit. Because it is a bit bulky due to the stability and cushioning of the shoe, it would be best suitable for forwards and centers rather than a quick guard. Great shoe!