I liked these boots
more in the picture than in person. The description of "tooled leather" is inaccurate. As the box states, it's embossed -- a big difference -- and I should have known that from the price. The leather is not exactly bad looking, but not nearly what I expected. Overall, I thought the boots
looked rather clunky. After my brother saw them on me during my "walking around the house phase" of the decision process and seriously asked if I was wearing snow boots
to go out and shovel, I decided that I had been right about them looking clunky. Back they go. As for the fit, I ordered the WW and they were plenty roomy in the foot, a real plus! But I found the calf to be snug, fine with wuthout pants
in, but if you want to wear them with your pant leg inside, I imagine that for most people it will be a tight fit. My calves are not large by any stretch of the imagination so unless you have really skinny legs, wearing these with pants
tucked in may not work for you. The construction and quality of the boot were good and reflective of the moderate price. If I could give these a 3.5, I would, but went with a 4 because of the overall construction and quality.