Continue playing Product Showdown

Product Showdown

aka Shoe-Jitsu, Shoe-mo Wrestling, Shoe Duel, and a number of other witty names we couldn't decide on.

BCBGeneration Pollye

Battle Stats

  • Total Wins: 5
  • Total Losses: 0
  • Wins vs. Competitor: 1
  • Sales Rank: #20099
  • The squared toe on this versatile flat make this slip-on stunning.
  • Leather upper.
  • Oversized metal buckle ornament at toe.
  • Elasticized band at heel for a customized fit.
  • Lightly padded insole.
  • Rubber outsole.
  • Weight: 6 oz
  • Product measurements were taken using size 7. Please note that measurements may vary by size.
  • Check out these comfort-enhancing accessories:

Average Customer Ratings (based on 9 reviews)

Overall: (4 Stars) Comfort: (3 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)

Posted: 2007-10-24 10:57:40
Reviewer: Deb from Spirit Lake, Ia
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (4 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Deb Spirit Lake, IA - Cute shoe! Felt true to size and feels like you are wearing slippers. A little tight in the width of the shoe.
Posted: 2007-11-05 14:20:32
Reviewer: Heather from Kentucky
Overall: (4 Stars) Comfort: (2 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Cute as can be!! I love these shoes and I have had several compliments, but the back of my heel hurts after a few minutes of wearing them. I usually have to have 2 band-aids for each heel when I wear them. They are cute, but the overall comfort is not good. I can barely stand to wear them for a full day of work.
Posted: 2007-11-07 13:44:00
Reviewer: Anonymous from Washington DC
Overall: (4 Stars) Comfort: (2 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Love them...but they hurt my heel - These shoes are so cute and I get so many compliments. I usually wear in between an 8.5 and 9. I should have purchased the 9 because they hurt like heck in the back. They dig into my heels really bad. Otherwise, the overall support is very good.
Posted: 2007-12-14 14:44:43
Reviewer: Peppysfriend from Eastern Shore, Lake Ontario
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (4 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Cute shoe - I really, really like the look of this flat, a good basic that goes with everything, yet not dull. Love the big buckle and the square toe makes it comfortable. The elastic in the back rubbed my heel, too. I bought some Band-Aid Blister Block and it helped a lot in the short run. I have not worn the shoe for a full day with this product yet, but would not hesitate to do so. It seems to do what it says!
Posted: 2008-01-04 13:06:57
Reviewer: Anonymous from Detroit, Michigan
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Very Cute! This shoe is very cute and stylish, but I have to agree with the other reviews in that the back of the shoe is irritating. I ended up having to get a whole size larger because of it. The size increase helped a lot. But otherwise the shoes are fabulous!
Posted: 2008-02-29 14:05:14
Reviewer: Anonymous
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Pollye - This shoe was hurting the back of my heel, too, but here’s the trick... for a day maybe around the house, walk on the back of the heel... somehow this does help for when you go 2 wear it out it doesn't rub against your heel as bad. Also wear stockings, that helps, too...
Posted: 2008-04-01 14:23:01
Reviewer: Katie A from Minnetonka, MN
Overall: (4 Stars) Comfort: (4 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
So Classy! I got a pair of the pewter Pollyes which zappos doesn't have, but they are very cute! It was odd because I initially tried on a size 6 and they seemed to fit okay. I was dumbfounded because I'm typically a size 7, so I went up to a size 6 1/2, which I felt more comfortable with. The fit doesn't seem to be a problem and I wouldn't go up a size, however, I wore them around my college campus for a half day and they rubbed the back of my heels horribly. Next time I will wear band-aids or something. I wouldn't let that stop one from buying these shoes though.
Posted: 2008-05-01 22:34:33
Reviewer: Anonymous from New York
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (4 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Cute shoes! I have these shoes in pewter and they're adorable! Goes great with almost any outfit. It's pretty comfortable- at first digs in the back, until you get used to it. I got a half size smaller than I am and it fits fine (my real size, 8.5, was a bit big). It's a great buy!
Posted: 2008-06-01 18:13:54
Reviewer: Anonymous
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (4 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Great shoes - I usually have a hard time with shoes this style (low front and very open) because I have a bunion on one of my feet. These are comfortable. To help ease the pain of the elastic back I put in Dr. Scholl's heel grips and it made it 1000 times more comfortable. They look great and they are so nice.

Minnetonka Kilty Suede Moc

Battle Stats

  • Total Wins: 167
  • Total Losses: 196
  • Wins vs. Competitor: 0
  • Sales Rank: #152
  • Video Description View the Video Description for this product! (Please note that the color shown in the video may no longer be available.)
  • The vintage-inspired Kilty Suede Moc from Minnetonka® has a timeless style that will go with almost anything!
  • Soft suede upper with whip-stitch accents and kilty fringe design for a stylish appeal.
  • Leather lining and cushioned footbed offers enhanced comfort and support with each step.
  • Indoor/outdoor rubber outsole with grip pods and flex grooves delivers durable grip to sturdy your stride.

Average Customer Ratings (based on 630 reviews)

Overall: (4 Stars) Comfort: (4 Stars) Style: (4 Stars)

Posted: 2000-11-10 07:10:40
Reviewer: Karen from Phoenix, AZ
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
I never dreamed they would be so comfy! My mom loves to wear moccasins around the house and kept wearing hers out. She had trouble finding replacements, so I thought I'd buy her some for Christmas. OK, maybe I should try some too. They arrived in less than 1 week, and when I put them on my feet, I was *amazed* at how perfectly they fit and how extraordinarily comfortable they are. They are my new weekend shoes and I am so sold on them that I have vowed to never again be without a pair.
Posted: 2002-01-16 05:35:07
Reviewer: Alex B from Columbia, SC
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Comfort shoes. Working in retail, and being on my feet at least 8 hours a day/five days a week, these shoes are comfortable and relaxing for my feet.
Posted: 2002-08-28 22:30:27
Reviewer: Vicky R from Hertford,NC
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Great. I have wanted a pair of these shoes since I lived in MN ,but other than the expensive western stores or, an occasional pair in a well stocked truck stop, either the price or the lack of my size deterred me. I found this website quite by accident,( my nephrew wanted skate shoes for his birthday) and while I was ordering I saw the brand. I assumed they would have a limited selection of shoes and sizes, So I was pleasently suprised to find out that I was wrong. My shoes were here in 4 days (with FREE shipping), and they fit like a glove. I was even able to buy my usual size! Anyway, now I'm going to have to buy more styles(sigh!)
Posted: 2002-10-09 02:37:06
Reviewer: Kristi B from North Dakota
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Found at last!! I've worn out a couple of the storm blue color mocs and I know where I can get replacements. But I've wanted the evergreen color for years and haven't been able to find them. A local dealer was not able to order them, even though he can get the other colors. I thought they were not being made any longer. I found them here and bought 2 pair. I'm going to ration my wearing of them in case I can never find them again.
Posted: 2002-11-03 15:49:21
Reviewer: Marcia S from Scottsdale, AZ
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Most comfortable shoes I own. I can't say enough good things about these moccasins. I have them in several colors and have replaced them only after I've worn them down to practically nothing. I can wear them all day and my feet feel wonderful.
Posted: 2006-05-19 15:28:52
Reviewer: Anonymous from Alabama
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (4 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Minnetonka's magnificent Mocks - I love these shoes; they go great with a pair of jeans and are very comfy. They do run about a half size small, I ordered up.
Posted: 2006-05-28 20:40:05
Reviewer: Anonymous from Chicago, Illinois
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Great! These shoes are some of the most comfortable shoes in the world! They're great, because they can be worn with jeans and a tee, and also look great with black pants, at a semi-formal/business casual event! They're cute, stylish, and convenient. I have a pair in black and brown, and I got the brown ones repaired because they were so worn out, but I will never throw these out!
Posted: 2006-05-30 06:10:16
Reviewer: Anonymous from Long Island, New York
Overall: (4 Stars) Comfort: (4 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Minnetonka suede mocks - It seems that this shoe has to mold to your foot, it didn’t seem to have the contours of your usual shoe.
Posted: 2006-06-13 17:49:46
Reviewer: Anonymous from Philadelphia, PA
Overall: (4 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Cute and soooo comfortable - Would have given them 5 stars if there was a little more support--but!! They are so cute and feel so good on your feet-have ordered another pair in red.
Posted: 2006-08-13 08:09:48
Reviewer: Anonymous from Massachusetts
Overall: (5 Stars) Comfort: (5 Stars) Style: (5 Stars)
Super cute and comfy - I haven't gotten a chance to wear them much, but so far these shoes are great. I can't wait for the fall--I’ll be wearing them all the time!

Battle History

Previous Month May 2012
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31