 | |
 |
Do you own this product?
Write an online review and share your thoughts!
| - Fit Survey:
- 64% of Fit Survey Respondents said this shoe
"Felt a half size smaller than marked". - 83% of Fit Survey Respondents said this shoe
"Felt true to width". - 72% of Fit Survey Respondents said this shoe had
"Excellent arch support".
|
| |
|
| | Do you own this product? ( Keen Calistoga )
Write an online review and share your thoughts with other Zappos.com customers!
| 64% of Fit Survey respondents said this shoe "Felt a half size smaller than marked"
83% of Fit Survey respondents said this shoe "Felt true to width"
72% of Fit Survey respondents said this shoe had "Excellent arch support"
Customer Rating/Review
Keen Calistoga
Number of reviews: 427
Average customer ratings:
Overall:
 Comfort: Look:
2009-11-06 05:45:30 Keen Calistoga
Reviewer:
Ruth S
from Slidell, Louisiana
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
I bought two pairs! They are extremely comfortable, with good arch support. The fit is roomy, so you can wear them with socks, tights, or barefoot. Mostly, I think they are very cute! I have another pair of Keen shoes that I bought last summer. I love them, too! The Mary Jane style looks great with skirts or pants.
Other brands recommended by reviewer: Archipedico
2009-10-28 05:19:18 Keen Calistoga
Reviewer:
Sue K
from New Jersey
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
These shoes are super comfortable and suitable for travel. My feet are very happy with these shoes.
Other brands recommended by reviewer: Teva, Dr. Martens
2009-10-24 06:08:11 Keen Calistoga
Reviewer:
Angie C
from Oregon
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
I had very serious foot surgery 7 1/2 months ago that requires that I wear extreme orthotics at all times. These shoes have removable insoles that allow me to insert my own orthotics. I wear these shoes all day and even use them as slippers around the house. They are very cute and very comfortable and have saved me from having to submit to wearing UGLY shoes. I also have the lace up version of this shoe that are equally cute and comfortable.
Other brands recommended by reviewer: I also love J-41 and Dansko, but can\'t wear them for awhile.
2009-10-23 12:44:01 Keen Calistoga
Reviewer:
Gretchen
from New Orleans
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
Oh boy! Decisions, decisions. Have purchased both the Keen Calistogas (so cute!) and the Winthrop clog. Can't keep them both. The clog is so comfy, my feet won't let them go. The Calistoga is a bit hard in the heel opening area with a thinner, rougher edge at the instep and heel. Sizing is weird; I wear a 10, which seem big, heels slips, ordered a 9.5, way too short. Seems more like a whole size difference than a half. The 10 fits better with orthotics and socks. The clogs are super comfy, but not the kind of shoe you can wear with skirts/dresses. I'm leaning toward these shoes in the hope they'll eventually break in and be a little more comfy. Arch support's not terrific, but I do wear the orthotics with them.
Other brands recommended by reviewer: Born
2009-10-20 17:29:32 Keen Calistoga
Reviewer:
Jessica C
from State College, Pa
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
I love the look of these shoes, but I found that the backs of the shoe where the heel goes in was sharp/abrasive. It messes up the back of the sock. I had to return them. I love the Sydney mary jane. There is a little pad on the back of the shoe. The old Seattle ones had the little padding, too. I am so sad because I love how the shoes look, but they made blisters on the back of my heels. I love all the Keen shoes I own though, and I own a lot!
Other brands recommended by reviewer: Teva, Privo, Clarks, Born
2009-10-16 09:00:45 Keen Calistoga
Reviewer:
Kirsten
from rocky mountains
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
Love them! At first I wasn't sure; they rubbed and felt tight on the top. One reviewer said that that goes away in 2-3 days; they were right. But then they started rubbing pretty fiercely on my heels. But now they are awesome and my favorite pair of shoes. Worth the breaking in time!
2009-10-11 14:58:40 Keen Calistoga
Reviewer:
Jennifer
from NC
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
I usually wear an eight in shoes like this so I ordered up based on the other reviews, but they were much too big even with the thickest socks I own.
2009-10-10 08:45:13 Keen Calistoga
Reviewer:
Karen T
from GA
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
These are great shoes. Very comfortable. The sizing is just a tad bigger than other shoes, but I didn\'t need to send them back for a smaller size. Love them!
2009-10-08 06:36:05 Keen Calistoga
Reviewer:
Anonymous
from Illinois
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
Shoe Size: Felt true to size
Shoe Width: Felt wider than marked
Shoe Arch: Moderate arch support
Calistoga vs. Sydney II - I bought both the Calistoga and Sydney II in brown with the intention of keeping one. Looking online, I thought I'd keep the Calistoga, but ended up liking the Sydney II better in person. The comparison: 1) nice flower detail on the Calistoga; 2) the Calistoga is a little darker brown than the Sydney II, but both a nice dark brown color; 3) the Sydney II has extra padding along the top strap and the Calistoga felt stiff around the seam where the Sydney had a softer feel; 4) the Sydney II is a little narrower throughout and has a slightly smaller toe box (but still the characteristic Keen big toe). So, for me, I went with the Sydney II as it felt more comfortable out of the box.
Other brands recommended by reviewer: Sydney II
2009-10-04 11:13:24 Keen Calistoga
Reviewer:
Rhonda L
from San Miguel de Allende, Mexico
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
Finally, a shoe that combines feminine style with walking comfort. In the past I refrained from buying "comfort" walking shoes because they were so unattractive. This shoe style fulfills my fashion sensibilities while providing a comfortable and secure sole to walk on the cobblestone streets of San Miguel de Allende.
2009-09-30 19:22:04 Keen Calistoga
Reviewer:
Nancy J
from Florence, MA
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
I love these shoes. They are sturdy and very comfortable. I opted for the purple and have gotten a lot of complements.
2009-09-29 09:52:12 Keen Calistoga
Reviewer:
Anonymous
from Evanston IL
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
I love these shoes! They fit loosely, but comfortably and true to size. They do not have as much arch support as some of my other Keens, but are still very comfortable. I get compliments on them every time I wear them. I can wear them with socks or without, but when wearing them without, it took a few short walks to break them in.
2009-09-21 06:43:22 Keen Calistoga
Reviewer:
Anonymous
from Vermont
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
I ordered the size 11, and my feet were swimming around in the shoes. I then ordered a 10.5, and they fit much better. Cute shoes and I am glad I can put my custom insoles in them.
2009-09-18 07:47:35 Keen Calistoga
Reviewer:
Anonymous
from Seattle, WA
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
I love these shoes. I wore them in Las Vegas and got 3 compliments in the first hour! I love these shoes because they are rugged with a feminine touch. I buy shoes for a big toe box. That's why I buy Keen. I wish Zappos would rate more shoes that have the wider toe box.
Other brands recommended by reviewer: Ryka
2009-09-18 04:46:42 Keen Calistoga
Reviewer:
Anonymous
from Billings Montana
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
The Keens are great shoes. I have very small and wide feet secondary to a form of muscular dystrophy and these shoes accommodate my orthotics. Thanks to Zappos for their incredible customer service.
Other brands recommended by reviewer: halflinger clogs
2009-09-15 10:46:31 Keen Calistoga
Reviewer:
Andrea C
from Santa Rosa, CA
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
I love these shoes! This is my second pair (my first pair wore out after three years). I teach and run after my own two toddlers, and I can comfortably wear these shoes all day.
2009-09-14 15:15:24 Keen Calistoga
Reviewer:
Kellee C
from Denver, CO
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
The shoes are great for people with arthritis and back issues. This is my second pair. I love them, and Zappos.
Other brands recommended by reviewer: not many- these shoes are the best other than good tennis shoes
2009-09-11 13:29:14 Keen Calistoga
Reviewer:
Colyn W
from Portland, OR
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
These are great shoes, very cute and comfortable. I have three pair, different colors. They do not all fit exactly the same; the black ones (two years old) are almost a half-size bigger for some reason, but socks make the difference. I wore them walking around Europe and never had one complaint about my feet. I've worn the soles down, but the tops are super comfy (wish they were indestructible soles). I wear almost nothing but Keens now.
2009-09-08 05:30:34 Keen Calistoga
Reviewer:
Anonymous
from Cleveland, Ohio
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
These are like walking on clouds. Super comfortable. Cute, too. I get compliments whenever I wear them. Based on other feedback I purchased a half size larger than normal, and they are a bit big. I kept the bigger size, though, because I like to wear thick wool socks in winter and figured this will work out just fine.
2009-08-19 16:19:20 Keen Calistoga
Reviewer:
Leesa Drake
from Chicago
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
These shoes run a little more narrow than the previous pair of Keen mary jane\'s I bought (about 3 yrs ago). But still a good fit, stylish and versitile. I love them for travel when I\'m doing a lot of walking but don\'t want gym shoes. These are perfect!
2009-08-16 23:21:12 Keen Calistoga
Reviewer:
Anonymous
from Durham NC
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
Very comfortable shoes after a few days of a breaking-in period. At first I wasn't sure, but now I am thrilled that I kept them. They do run very wide, but I was able to accommodate to this by buckling the buckle relatively tightly (which I needed to do despite my high instep). These are great shoes for traveling. They are comfortable and supportive for walking, but also nice enough for situations when sneakers won't do.
Other brands recommended by reviewer: J-41, Born
2009-08-16 05:33:34 Keen Calistoga
Reviewer:
Jacklarrysgirl
from Utah
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
Great wide comfy shoe. Keen\'s allow me to wear my natural size of 8 1/2. Perfect for on your feet all day comfort. Rounded toe design (which is why I LOVE Keens)are made for the natural shape of the human foot. I no longer have to buy 9\'s or higher to compensate for my wide foot. This pair is casual, but I do wear them to work with some skirt suits and trousers. I own them in brown too.
Other brands recommended by reviewer: Lassen or Dr. Scholl\'s for men
2009-08-14 21:07:16 Keen Calistoga
Reviewer:
Anonymous
from Maryland
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
The Keen Calistoga ran a half size larger (they are wide) than my Keen Sydney\'s and required an exchange for a smaller size. Zappos had excellent customer service and I received the second pair the following day. The purple is a fun color and the shoes are cute but the Calistoga\'s are not as comfortable as the Sydney\'s.
2009-08-08 09:47:52 Keen Calistoga
Reviewer:
Heather Harpster
from Fort Collins, CO
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
This is my second pair of Calistogas. They are comfortable enough to wear to work (I\'m a nurse) and cute enough to wear out and about. One of my favorite Keen characteristics is the slightly wider toe box.
2009-08-06 09:07:09 Keen Calistoga
Reviewer:
Anonymous
from Michigan
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
This is my second pair of Keens this summer, and the footbed/comfort can't be beat (as is the case with all of their shoes, basically). The Calistoga Mary Jane's aren't QUITE as comfortable as my other Keen shoes, though, only because the upper is more rigid (the heel area is actually rather hard, when compared to many other Keens which have elasticized-type material around the heel). Thus, these take some breaking-in, but once your feet are used to them, they're great. And again, you can't beat the comfort/support of the footbed. They're versatile, too, you can wear them with skirts/sundresses, shorts, jeans, you name it. In other words, you'll get your money's worth.
 Top
 | |
|
 |  | I bought almost a whole "winter wardrobe" from you in the last few weeks. And I want to thank you for your incredible service (phone, email, all and any contact w/ you) because it is outstanding. The items I bought are of the best quality, and I only had to return 2 items that either did not fit, and the necklace was an unattractive item. I exchanged both items for something else I wanted. Never ever did I have a negative experience with you in all the years I have been your customer. You make all the difference in shopping experiences, and I almost shop exclusively w/ you because of it. Whatever you pay your employees, isn't enough ;o) they are worth their weight in Gold. Overall, just thank you for everything, Sincerely, Adelheid J. |  | ~ Adelheid J., October 12 2009
| Read more testimonials!
|
Submit a video testimonial!
| | | |
Canadian Shoppers