Johnston & Murphy

This is a comfortable, well-made shoe. I require wide shoes (EE - 4E, depending on brand) and the EE Shuler Bike model fit me perfectly. Excellent arch support and workmanship as well.

My shoe order was right on time, and was exactly what I ordered. I am happy to recommend Zappos to my friends. I will be ordering again.

Business dress shoes have classic styling without being too dressy. Superb comfort for a leather soled shoe, these are possibly the most comfortable dress shoe I've ever owned.

Having narrow feet, these are one of the few offerings that come in a "B" width. They are pretty snug, so the lacing doesn't close as far as it should - based on the style of oxford laces. So far they have not broken in as much as I had hoped they would. The style is classically great, but there are some noticeable imperfections in the leather. I guess you have to go up to the $300-ish level to fix that.

I bought these shoes primarily for comfort / arch support. The padding is really soft and feels great but it literally covers the entire shoe, not just the heel or arch part, so my toes felt really crowded and my arch did not get any real support since it was on the same level as the rest of my feet.

The color was perfect but sizing is very narrow. Great looking shoe. I couldn't get my foot in the shoe without a shoehorn and then it was way too narrow and it is the same size I always wear in J&M shoes.

Wow, these are great! They go great with Jeans and are comfortable enough for all day & evening wear. Spent 2 straight days/nights walking and dancing without foot or leg soreness. The color of the leather was a bit lighter than what is pictured here - but will likely darken after a few polishes. One minor gripe is that the standard insole is likely to come out when taking them off - this started after about a week of wearing them. I generally replace the insoles with more comfortable inserts, so it's not a big deal for me.

I usually wear Bostonian, first pair of J&M. These shoes are great, so comfortable and look good with just about anything. The lamb skin lining is awesome, I love wearing these shoes. Bought black originally and liked so much ordered brown a couple weeks later. I am picky about my shoes, and these are by far the best shoes for someone on the go I have ever owned. They are light, no break in needed, and so soft inside with great breathability. . Zappos got them to me the next day, perfect all around.

Great feel and comfort for a wingtip right outta the box. Attention to detail and quality construction you definitely get from J&M with this shoe.

Nice shoe but the medium width was to narrow. I never have had to buy a wide shoe before. As they are made of leather over time the shoe will stretch some and hopefully be a good shoe.

These shoes are very classy shoes. They fit very well to size, maybe I just have large feet. They do take a while to break in and get comfortable but after that they are a very good shoe. They can be a pain to lace however.

Great comfortable shoes. I only wish it that Zappos could change the shoe market by having an extra pair of laces included with each pair! They are so nice for casual or dress that I do not want to take them off my feet. However, I do take them off to go to bed. Unless of course I am standing up and fall asleep. The other shoes that I have trouble taking off are Born Bolt and my Cole Haan's.

This is a great shoe! The dual width insole is pure genius. I am between medium and wide width, so removing the top footbed made it fit like a glove. Sturdy leather requires some break-in, but overall this is a solid, stylish shoe at a reasonable price.

Love the look and quality of this shoe but I couldn't get it on my foot. I have a high instep and that is where this shoe didn't work. My foot went in about 3/4 of the way and topped out at the tongue. There was no way in the world my foot was going into this shoe. I wish it would have. Love Zappos though.

Husband loved these shoes, so purchased a second black pair and a cordovan pair. They take 3-4 wearings to break in. Comfortable and classy. Great news is they can be sent in to J & M for refurbishment! Excellent value.

Shoes were very comfortable but two pairs in a row developed a very loud creaking noise in the sole after about two weeks. Thankfully I bought them from Zappos because they went out of their way to help me. Probably won't buy any more J&M's though, especially considering their price. Went back to Ecco.

Good looking shoe with excellent cushioning. The shoe was a full size too long, yet fit very snug around the rest of my foot. Also found these shoes to weigh more than typical.

I've worn the Melton for over 15 years. It was the first "expensive" dress shoe I ever purchased after college. It has a classic, conservative, clean look to it. One of the reasons I love this shoe is that it is a repairable shoe, so with care, maintenance, and occasional heel and sole replacement, you should get many years of use out of this phenomenal shoe. One of the other reasons I love this shoe is the need for me to wear an orthotic to balance out knee issues. The Melton provides ample space to allow for an orthotic to be worn while maintaining a superior level of comfort.

I've worn the Melton for over 15 years. It was the first "expensive" dress shoe I ever purchased after college. It has a classic, conservative, clean look to it. One of the reasons I love this shoe is that it is a repairable shoe, so with care, maintenance, and occasional heel and sole replacement, you should get many years of use out of this phenomenal shoe. One of the other reasons I love this shoe is the need for me to wear an orthotic to balance out knee issues. The Melton provides ample space to allow for an orthotic to be worn while maintaining a superior level of comfort. The Bordeaux version is a very, very dark burgundy color. At first glance, it may almost appear black. This should change over time, but be aware this is a very dark color.

Feel wonderful on your feet. I guess I would call these my comfort shoes. Very disappointed with the look though. Have a very plastic look. I truly didn't check to see if these are leather but if they are, it is a very, very poor grade of leather.