Frye James Penny SKU: #7650768

Anonymous

from new york

Too narrow! Very nice, has great potential to be the most comfortable shoe once broken in. My feet are narrow and petite, and these are too narrow and tight for me. Too bad! Still deciding whether to return or stretch these.

Brands I'd also recommend: alexander wang

Craige M

from Jersey City, NJ

These are very classy loafers. They are well-made and I think they will probably last a long time. The leather is a little stiff in the beginning. There was pressure on my toes at first, but never any blisters. And after wearing them for a few minutes, I would no longer feel the pressure. There is no room to insert any orthotics, which is good, actually, because if they were bigger, they would look like boats. The olive color is so gorgeous. Goes with anything!

Brands I'd also recommend: Dr. Marten, Fleuvog

Ellen

Thrilled with these shoes. My feet are fairly narrow--I'm usually able to wear regular width, but when fit is very important (running shoes, for example) I purchase a narrow width. These were fine width-wise for me. I also have fairly flat feet, to the point where I have ankle pain if I wear shoes without arch support for an extended period of time. I typically use SuperFeet insoles in shoes that do not have enough arch support initially. While these shoes have not yet been uncomfortable, I will be purchasing a set of insoles for them--they simply do not have enough arch support for me over the long run.

Erin B

from Indianapolis, IN

Seem a bit narrow, especially at first. However, broke in nicely and are extremely comfortable. Highly recommend!

Anonymous

from Houston

The ultimate loafer. I love these shoes. They are black and faded in some areas, which is cool. Pant legs usually cover up the faded areas. I can wear them with wide leg or straight leg pants. Like on the TV show TLC's What on to Wear, pointed toe is a more flattering shoe, which these are. The shoes are very sturdy. I wish they came in more colors. Worth the price. I can wear these to work with dress pants or casual on the weekend with jeans.

Brands I'd also recommend: Bass, Paul Green

Sydney

from Sioux Falls, SD

These are very cool loafers! I purchased the tan and I love the sort of distressed look of the leather. These shoes are made very well. Heavy-duty leather soles and fabulous craftsmanship (not made in China). They do run a bit narrow and can look long on the foot. I do think they run large, I sized down a whole size due to heel slippage. My feet are on the narrow side and my heels tend to slip, so sizing down worked for me. Love them!

Brands I'd also recommend: Cole Haan

Anonymous

Beware! These are narrower than the other Frye James models. I have the oxford and the wingtip, and love them. But I fear these may never break in. I have a wide foot, high instep/arch, but the other Fryes all fit in a 7.5. These, not so much.

Anonymous

from Minnesota

I got these in the red which is a great color but they run very large. I wondered if they are a men's shoe that ended in the women's shoes.

Lisbeth C

from Ocala, FL

I have a narrow foot, and this shoe seemed to run a 1/2 size too long. I have other shoes from Frye that fit well at a size 9, but my heels slipped right out of these loafers in size 9. However, they are a great shoe and I've already ordered a half size down.